Facebook Twitter Pinterest Google+ Addthis

Planning to make changes to SEND funding

The funding provision for children with Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) is under pressure and faces increasing demand and limited funding. There is currently an overspend in this area and the council will have to make difficult choices to address this. 

We have started a process of listening to families and others directly affected by this funding situation. At these meetings we have listened to parents and students and considered suggestions for how we manage SEND services better whilst having to work with less funding. 

This survey asks for the views of residents, parents of children with SEND and practitioners about proposed ways to reduce how much we spend, so we can balance the books, as well as update the support from key Council services. It lays out some options for how the council can make changes for our provision so that we can provide support to SEND children and young people. The options we are laying out will help us decide on the measures we must take.

We are asking for your views in relation to three areas, funding to our schools, changes to the Support for Learning Service (SLS) and changes to the Behaviour and Attendance support service (BASS). 

 

Summary

Government funding and SEND

How the funding is being used and why this needs to change

How we have developed the proposals

The proposals and what impact these could have

Have your say

Timetable for the consultation, decision making and implementation process

Summary

There are around 8000 children and young people in Tower Hamlets, between the ages of 2 and 25, who have Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND) or attending Alternative Education provision (AP). 3000 children and young people have an Education, Health and Care plan (EHCP). The Local Authority (LA), working with partners, is committed to doing all we can to ensure these children and young people have every chance to fulfil their ambitions and to thrive.

The government provides funding through the High Needs Funding Block (HNFB), to the LA to support the education of children and young people with SEND and those attending AP. Most of this money is paid to schools and a small proportion, about 5%, is kept by the LA to pay for services. The demand on this budget is such that the LA is now consulting on ways to make changes to school funding and service provision. 

In 2018-19, Tower Hamlets received £49.7 million for SEND funding, but spent more than £56million. If we do not make changes we estimate by 2022 the overspend will reach circa £12 million. This overspend needs to be off set through other school budgets, reducing spending elsewhere in the education system. This is a national problem and the government is asking for evidence and views about problems with the amount of SEND funding: 

Proposed changes to top-up payments for children with an EHCP

As the bulk of the HNFB goes to schools and other providers, the LA is considering a reduction in top-up amounts to move Tower Hamlets top ups to be closer to other similar London boroughs. Within a context of all funding to schools reducing, this particular reduction may have an impact on the educational offer in schools and other provision.

Proposed changes to the Support for Learning Service and the Behaviour aspect of the Behaviour and Attendance Support Service

The proposal is that the LA maintains a core service so that statutory duties are fully met, as well as retaining capacity to respond to emerging concerns for example in meeting the needs of children with SEMH and work on reducing exclusions. The consultation asks questions ask about different ways of making changes which are likely to result in a change or reduction in the current staffing in SLS and BASS.

During May and early June, the LA ran 15 facilitated events for parents, carers and other stakeholders to discuss and give their views on how the HNFB is currently used and to make suggestions about what changes could be made. Feedback from these sessions has informed the questions in this consultation. 

Government funding and SEND

All schools receive an amount of money for each pupil. In Tower Hamlets the per/pupil amount (calculated using the LA School Block allocation divided by the total number of pupils in primary and secondary schools) is currently £6912 per annum. For pupils that have additional needs but do not meet the threshold for an EHCP, the school receives an additional £6000. This money is included in the basic school funding.  This is known as ‘notional funding’.

The government gives every LA an annual grant for SEND and to fund alternative education provision (AP), from the High Needs Funding Block (HNFB). The amount paid to the LA is based on a formula, but this does not take account of recent pupil numbers and many LAs nationally are experiencing difficulties in meeting their commitments within this budget.  

The funding provided by the Government has failed to increase in a way which meets the increase in needs.  Since 2016/17 there has been a 43% increase in the number of children with an EHCP.  However the amount of money the LA receives from the government has only increased by 5.2%.

How the funding is being used and why this needs to change

For pupils with an EHCP attending mainstream schools, their level of need identifies which ‘Band’ of SEND funding they will receive. In Tower Hamlets there are five bands- Band A which equates to a top up of £7,085 to Band E which equates to a top up of £16,296. For pupils attending a special school, a specialist resource base in a mainstream school or AP, the amount of top up is based on the school they attend. 

The amount of these top ups varies between different boroughs, with Tower Hamlets schools receiving more than similar schools in other comparable boroughs.

The LA is currently working on updating the descriptors for the banding system to clarify what level of need falls within each band and which children are eligible for an EHCP. This work will be rolled out in the next financial year. 

Top-up amounts Tower Hamlets mainstream schools by SEND band

 Bands

 Top-up 2018-2919 (per pupil, per year)

 A

 £7,085

 B

 £8,502

 C

 £11,053

 D

 £12,753

 E

£16,296

 

Top-up payments at Tower Hamlets special schools and alternative provision

 School Top-up 2018-2019 (per pupil per year)

Severe learning difficulties/profound and multiple learning difficulties schools (SLD/PMLD)

Stephen Hawking [ages 3 – 11]

 

Beatrice Tate [ages 11 – 18]

 

 

£18,568

 

20,232

Social emotional and mental health difficulties schools (SEMH)

Cherry Trees [ages 5 – 11]

 

Ian Mikardo  [ages 11 – 18]

 

 

£18,076

 

£25,763

Residential school 

Social emotional and mental health difficulties schools (SEMH)

Bowden House  [ages 10 – 18]

 

 

 

£52,902

 Autistic Spectrum Disorder 

Phoenix  [ages 3 – 18]

 

£20,232

 

 

 Alternative Education Provision (AP)

 

London East Alternative Provision (LEAP)

Group teaching

Individual teaching

 

£11,173

£27,764

 South Quay College

Group teaching

Individual teaching

 

£11,500

£28,000

 Mainstream School (with special resource unit)

 Top-up 2018-2019 (per pupil per year)

 Bangabandhu Primary School (PD)

 £7,025

 Culloden Primary Academy (HI)

 £9,662

 Cyril Jackson Primary School (SLCN)

 £3,732

 Globe Primary School (SLCN)

 £3,732

 Hague Primary School (HI)

 £5,392

 George Green’s School (PD)

 £8,270

St Paul’s Way Trust School (HI)

£5,885

 

Hackney

Top ups for mainstream schools in Hackney
 Bands  Top-up rate 2018-2019
 A  £4,736
 B  £6,077
 C  £6,500
 D  £11,432
 E  £15,818

 

Top-ups for special schools in Hackney
 School Top-up 2018-2019
 1  £15,000
 2  £20,000
 3  £25,000

 

Southwark

Top-ups for mainstream schools in Southwark
 Bands Top-up rate 2018-2019
 A  £4,000
 B  £8,000
 C  £12,000
 D  £16,000

 

Top-ups for special schools in Southwark
 School Top-up 2018-2019
 1 (SLD - sec)  £13,212
 2 (SEMH - primary)  £17,568
 3 (ASD - primary)  £18,906
 4 (ASD - sec)  £19,030
 5 (PMLD/SLD - sec)  £19,629
 6 (PMLD/SLD - primary)  £20,247

 

Lewisham

Top-ups for mainstream schools in Lewisham
 Bands Top-up rate 2018-2019
 A  £5,620
 B  £8,640
 C  £12,150

 

Top-ups for special schools in Lewisham
 School Top-up 2018-2019
 1  £6,200
 2  £15,200
 3  £27,900

 

The SLS comprises of teams of specialist staff who provide services for children with SEND. A contribution is also made to the Behaviour aspect of the Behaviour and Attendance Support Services (BASS).  The SLS and BASS have worked in the same way over a number of years and we need to make changes to ensure the LA meets all its statutory responsibilities through the services provided. Even if there were no funding pressures, the SLS and BASS would have to change in response to: 

  • Changes in the LA’s statutory duties ( for example those introduced through the Children and Families Act 2014)

  • Emerging government policy in relation to social, emotional and mental health and school exclusions

  • Changes in the SEND needs of pupils over time

  • Feedback from school leaders

  • Feedback from parents. 

How we have developed the proposals 

The proposals for change have been informed by considering:

  • how well the LA meets its statutory duties – currently the LA services are focused on school aged pupils but there are gaps in the age 16-25 provision and during the school holidays

  • whether or not all schools have equal access to services funded by retained funding – we are concerned that this is not happening at present

  • whether the LA provides a fair level of support to meet the different types of SEND – we want to meet the needs of children with all different needs

  • what happens in other LAs which are similar to Tower Hamlets

  • a review of how the HNFB is spent in collaboration with headteachers

  • how we encourage all schools to take their fair share pupils with EHCPs

  • a review of the SLS and BASS

  • changes in responsibilities for the LA, for example the Timpson review which will require the LA to support schools to reduce exclusions 

  • whether or not LA services provide value for money

  • if can we invest more money in early intervention as a way of getting better outcomes for pupils. 

Tower Hamlets is committed to inclusion across all educational establishments and the following set of principles are helping us to shape the changes that are made:

  • Choice a SEND system with a ‘mixed economy’ of provision.

  • Good quality: We want to offer choice for parents and carers and a range of good educational opportunities for children and young people.

  • Clarity: Make evidence-based decisions with transparency.

  • Fairness:

    • Financial fairness with regular reporting about SEND budgets.

    • Support offered equitably to all with an EHC plan up to age 25; according to need, in order to achieve improved outcomes.

    • Equity of access to funding, support and service for schools and colleges, in proportion to need (e.g. number and proportion with an EHC plan).

  • Effectiveness: services for children and young people with SEND should avoid duplication and place a strong emphasis on capacity building

 

The proposals and what impact these could have

Proposed changes to top-up payments for children with an EHCP

As the bulk of the HNFB goes to schools, the LA is considering a reduction in top-up amounts to move Tower Hamlets top ups to be closer to other similar London boroughs. Within a context of all funding to schools reducing, this particular reduction may have an impact on the educational offer in schools. 

Bringing top up funding in line with other boroughs could make some money available for early intervention which would help improve outcomes for pupils and reduce the need for an EHCP as the pupil gets older.

We would also like your views on making changes to reduce the differences in top up that currently exist between different kinds of special school- for example, for pupils attending PMLD schools primary and secondary pupils receive a different top up amount, whereas for pupils attending the ASD school, the top up is the same for primary and secondary pupils.

Proposed changes to the Support for Learning Service and the Behaviour aspect of the Behaviour and Attendance Support Service 

The SLS services would need to change even if there were no budget pressures. Following a review of services, we have identified need to make changes so that we fully meet statutory duties. At the moment:

  • Most support is for children and young people in a school setting, though the sensory impairment team (specialist teachers for visual and hearing impairment, part of the SLS) works with pre-school children.

  • As a consequence of the way the budget is currently allocated, there is little support is offered to pupils with SEND who are older than 16 but the LA has a duty to support young people with an EHCP up to the age of 25.

  • The SLS currently offers a term time only service

  • The LA is not providing an equitable level of advice and guidance on the full range of special needs in the pupil cohort, , with a particular gap in services for Autistic Spectrum Disorder

  • Whilst there may be a role for some services in early intervention work, little more than half of the pupils seen by SLS and BASS have an EHCP.

SLS and BASS deliver ‘core’ activity free of charge to schools.  The core activity total budget is £2,798,499. Currently it is unclear which aspects of the work delivered are statutory and those which are non-statutory. Individual teams work in different ways - some being more focused on individual case work and others on working with professionals.

The proposal is that the LA maintains a core service so that statutory duties are fully met, as well as retaining capacity to respond to emerging concerns for example in meeting the needs of children with SEMH and work on reducing exclusions.

To make best use of resources, the LA’s view is that these services should be working mainly with school staff to help all schools develop their inclusive practice and only working with individual children in agreed circumstances when it is clear there are benefits to this way of working. In some circumstances, it may be more effective and better value for money for a service to be provided by commissioning from a school rather than the LA providing a service.

Have your Say

The consultation period will run from 24 June to 25 July 2019

You are invited to respond to this consultation by completing the feedback form online.

Give your feedback

 

 

Alternatively, you can email your comments to Send.Strategy@towerhamlets.gov.uk by 25 July 2019

Timetable for the consultation, decision making and implementation process 

The consultation period will run from the 24 June to 25 July 2019

Below is the estimated timetable for the decision making process:

 Date Activity

 24 June

Consultation commences 

 2 July 2019 , 9.30am-11am

Consultation meeting – PDC, 229 Bethnal Green Rd, London E2 6AB

Focus groups with children and young people will be conducted throughout the consultation period

 16 July 2019, 5.30pm

Consultation meeting – PDC , 229 Bethnal Green Rd, London E2 6AB

 17 July 2019, 6.00pm

Consultation meeting – Parents Advice Centre, 30 Greatorex St. E1 5NP 

 23 July 2019, 2-5pm

Consultation meeting – PDC 229 Bethnal Green Rd, London E2 6AB

 24 July 2019

 End of consultation

 Late July 2019

 Collate report on the response of the consultation and initial findings

 August -September 2019

Report on the response of the consultation to the Mayor and consideration of proposals.

Report on the response of the consultation and consideration of proposals to be discussed at School Forum

October 2019

Consideration of detailed proposals

April 2020

Implementation